Insights to Help Your Business

Self-Insurance vs. Shipping Insurance: What’s Best for You? 

What are the common pitfalls of self-insurance, and is shipping insurance worth it? 

If you run an e-commerce business, you know that shipping is crucial. It ultimately helps create a smooth experience for customers. How you respond is especially important when things go wrong, like damaged packages or lost deliveries. Your actions matter just as much as the sale itself. 

This is where the debate between self-insurance and shipping insurance comes into play. Throughout this article, we’ll explore the pitfalls of self-insurance while highlighting why InsureShield Shipping Insurance is the smarter choice for protecting your shipments and your business. 

What Is Self-Insurance? 

Self-insurance means a business assumes the financial risk of shipping problems. Instead of having an insurance policy, they manage the risk themselves. Rather than going through the insurance middleman, self-insured companies rely on a pool of funds to cover losses. It sounds simple, but “self-insuring” can become a logistical and financial hassle, especially for businesses without considerable resources. 

Back view of young businesswoman using laptop with blank screen mockup at workplace in office, copy space

The Hidden Costs of Self-Insurance 

  • Unpredictable Expenses: One of the main downsides of self-insurance is being unable to predict costs. Shipping mishaps are more common than ever today. With package thefts and damage rising, even a handful of incidents can drain your "insurance fund" and impact profit margins. 
  • Administrative Burden: Managing claims internally takes time and resources. This time could be better used to grow your business. 
  • Customer Dissatisfaction: When you don’t resolve a claim quickly or fairly, you risk damaging customer relationships. Dissatisfied customers are less likely to return, and negative reviews can harm your reputation. 
  • Limited Technology Support: Finally, many self-insured tools allow users to pool funds to cover losses. However, a self-insured tech stack may not have the specific features businesses need for good claims management. Many find themselves frustrated by limited automation, lack of customization, or gaps in coverage. 

Why InsureShield Protection Is Better for Your Business than Self-Insurance 

InsureShield Shipping Insurance offers complete coverage and a simple claims process. This gives businesses of all shapes and sizes peace of mind. Here are some benefits: 

  • Predictable Costs: With InsureShield Coverage, choose between percentage-based pricing or a rate of $100 to qualify. Knowing the actual cost of your shipping insurance is better than taking chances with fluctuating losses. This predictability helps you budget effectively and protects your bottom line. 
  • Simplified Claims Process: We are unrivaled in handling claims. Our fast and easy claims process means less stress for you and a better experience for your customers. Forget the hassle of manually investigating claims—we have got you covered. 
  • Comprehensive Multi-Carrier Coverage: InsureShield Shipping Insurance offers comprehensive coverage that covers all modes and carriers. It also covers many situations, like lost or stolen packages and damage during transit. We make shipping insurance easy, so you can always rely on us.
  • Reduces Financial Risk: By transferring the risk of shipping mishaps to us, your business can avoid significant financial hits. This ensures your cash flow always stays consistent, which is especially important during peak seasons like the holidays.
  • Protects Customer Relationships: Customers appreciate quick resolutions. You can trust us to process claims efficiently, which helps maintain customer satisfaction and fosters loyalty and repeat business.

Self-Insurance Options vs. InsureShield Protection 

Many of these self-insured tech stacks rely on pooled funds, which might not be sufficient for larger claims or high-volume shippers. InsureShield Protection provides broad coverage for many shipping problems. This is different from self-insurance pools, which may not fully cover e-commerce businesses.

When you transfer the risk to us, you always keep your business protected from unexpected financial hits. This helps you and your business maintain customer satisfaction and foster repeat business. With us, you have a genuine insurance company and coverage, no matter what. 

Is Self-Insurance Worth It? 

Self-insurance can work for businesses with: 

  • Significant financial reserves 
  • Dedicated staff to manage claims 
  • Low shipping volumes 

However, the risks outweigh the benefits for most small and medium-sized businesses. Self-insuring means taking on unnecessary stress and financial exposure—burdens we can help you eliminate. 

Make the Smarter Choice for Your Business 

InsureShield Shipping Insurance provides the protection, ease, and reliability your business needs to thrive. With our services, you can focus on growing your business while we handle the risks. 

Switch from self-insurance to InsureShield Shipping Insurance today!

Additional Resources

Close up of hands using a smart phone by a laptop

Insights to Help Your Business

How the FTC’s New Regulations Will Reshape Checkout Protection (And How to Stay Ahead)

Why your current shipping protection model could be putting you at risk.

Insights to Help Your Business

Navigating Shipping Claims

Discover the secrets to streamlining your business and learn the keys to navigating a seamless and fast shipping claims experience with InsureShield® Shipping Protection.

Close up of hands holding and placing a shipping label on a box

Insights to Help Your Business

What Is Shipping Insurance?

Learn how shipping protection can help safeguard your business. Mitigating risks surrounding packages in transit can give you extra peace of mind.

Male in a safety vest and hard hat holding a tablet in a warehouse

Insights to Help Your Business

Mastering the Complexities of International Shipping

Protect Your E-commerce Business with InsureShield® Coverage.

Broken plate in damaged cardboard box top view, damaged home delivery unpacking box close up

Insights to Help Your Business

How to Prevent Shipping Damages in E-commerce Deliveries

As an e-commerce business owner, you hold the key to preventing shipping damage. Every shipment you send out carries the potential for damage, and it's in your hands to mitigate this risk. Remember, shipping damage not only costs you money but can also tarnish your hard-earned reputation.

Table with laptop and gift boxes with sale tags on table in warehouse. Online ecommerce retail business black friday discounts deals, free shipping. Best buy holiday offers concept storage background.; Shutterstock ID 1832266981; purchase_order: Ted Bruner; job: ; client: ; other:

Insights to Help Your Business

Preparing for Peak Shipping Season 2024: 7 Tips for Success
Here is your guide on how to prepare for peak shipping season as an e-commerce business in 2024.
Female smiling at the camera in front of a computer and warehouse

Insights to Help Your Business

What is the Difference Between Shipping and Delivery?

We want to help you improve customer relationships and keep expectations clear with our simple shipping and delivery guide.

Female checking a box while surrounded by multiple boxes in a warehouse

Insights to Help Your Business

Are Retailers Ready for Peak Returns Season?

The holiday rush might boost your sales, but is your business properly prepared for the surge in returns?

Semi-truck driving down an empty country road

Insights to Help Your Business

How Weather Risks Impact the Shipping Industry

Protect your business from extreme weather and avoid costly damages and delays.

Male wearing safety gear entering a shipping containers information into a device

Insights to Help Your Business

Cargo Theft Insurance: What Every Merchant Needs to Know in 2025

Protect your shipments from fraud, cyber scams, and theft with the right coverage.

Warehouse shelves full of boxes

Insights to Help Your Business

Understanding Shipping and Estimated Delivery Dates

Discover the important differences between different dates for shipping and receiving packages.

Male wearing a mask and using a laptop in a warehouse full of boxes

Insights to Help Your Business

Supply Chain Risk Management: Always Stay Ahead

Tips for mitigating risks and protecting your business against global supply chain challenges.

Insights to Help Your Business

Top Shipping Stats and Tips Merchants Should Know in 2025

As we enter 2025, understanding key shipping statistics can help merchants refine their strategies, optimize operations, and boost customer satisfaction. 

Three packages sitting on the porch of a closed business

Insights to Help Your Business

Complete Guide to the Cost of Shipping Insurance

Compare carrier rates and discover the benefits of an InsureShield® policy.

Airplane wing over land with the sunrise behind it

Insights to Help Your Business

UPS Capital Unveils DeliveryDefense™ Technology

Empowering Merchants with Advanced Data Analytics to Identify High-Risk Deliveries

Warehouse worker talking on the phone holding clipboard in a large warehouse; Shutterstock ID 252244078; purchase_order: Channel Partner; job: ; client: ; other:

Insights to Help Your Business

Winning Shipping Strategies Merchants Need for 2025

From reliability to real-time tracking, getting shipping right is critical for boosting customer satisfaction and loyalty.

Hands on a laptop with analysis graphs on the screen

Insights to Help Your Business

Texas Precious Metals
Discover how DeliveryDefense™ Address Confidence elevates Texas Precious Metals shipping game.
Two packages sitting on a welcome mat in front of a door

Insights to Help Your Business

DeliveryDefenseData Transforms E-Commerce Logistics and Reduces Losses

Minimize Losses, Maximize Efficiency – Your Secret Weapon for 2024!

 

Male UPS driver carrying two packages down a flower lined sidewalk

Insights to Help Your Business

The Expedited Shipping Challenge: Balancing Speed, Cost, and Customer Satisfaction

Businesses must balance speed and affordability while managing the complexities of rising consumer expectations.

Two forklifts stacked on top each other going between shelves of boxes

Insights to Help Your Business

The Global Retail Race is Heating Up: How U.S. Merchants Can Compete

International retailers are driving notable changes domestically, with 85% of merchants surveyed reporting adjustments to their shipping strategies to keep up.

Shipping Challenges Statistics of what challenges AI can solve for

Insights to Help Your Business

Revolutionizing eCommerce:  UPS Capital Unveils AI-Driven Future of Shipping and Customer Satisfaction

Rapid eCommerce growth drives unprecedented shipping challenges

Insights to Help Your Business

Technology is Driving the Future of Shipping and the Supply Chain

The shipping industry is transforming

Close up of a pharmacist pulling medicine from a pharmacy box

Insights to Help Your Business

eCommerce Healthcare and Delivery: Annual Checkup

Examining the transformative trends shaping the healthcare supply chain in eCommerce.

Female sticking labels on a wire shelf holding packages

Insights to Help Your Business

Beat the Holiday Rush: 7 Ways Retailers Can Prepare for Peak Shipping Season
In this guide, we'll explore key strategies to help retailers gear up for the peak shipping season. Discover best practices for managing increased demand, ensuring timely deliveries and safeguarding your shipments with insurance.
Male and female looking in a jewelry store display window

Insights to Help Your Business

How to Prepare for Black Friday and Cyber Monday

Black Friday and Cyber Monday are great opportunities for your business to thrive. Use this guide to help prepare your e-commerce business for the online shopping holiday rush.

Female sitting on a couch with her hands in an open box

Insights to Help Your Business

Personalized Shipping Experiences: The Next Frontier for eCommerce Report

Learn what consumers are looking for in an online experience.

Male sitting on a couch and using a laptop

Insights to Help Your Business

Stay Ahead of the Claims Game

Time-saving tips for a smooth claims process.

Insights to Help Your Business

InsureShield® Shipping Insurance vs. Veeqo: Understanding the Differences

In the world of e-commerce shipping, there are many coverage options to choose from when it comes to protecting your business and your customers. With so much noise out there, it's essential to understand the nuances in what's available so you can rest easy knowing you are leveraging the best coverage option. Amazon's newest shipping software, Veeqo, may seem appealing to the eye but when compared to InsureShield Shipping Insurance - there's really no comparison at all. Read on to learn more.

Insights to Help Your Business

UPS Capital Unveils How Merchants Can Thrive Amid Surge in Global eCommerce

Use these key insights and solutions to enhance your 2024 shipping experience and equip you with the ability to thrive in the rapidly evolving eCommerce landscape.

Insights to Help Your Business

Reverse Logistics Jeopardy
Test your knowledge and skills on reverse logistics with our jeopardy game!
Woman sitting on the couch, opening a box.

Insights to Help Your Business

Revolutionizing eCommerce: UPS Capital Unveils AI-Driven Future of Shipping and Customer Satisfaction

Rapid eCommerce growth drives unprecedented shipping challenges

Male handing a bottle of wine to a female in a shop

Insights to Help Your Business

Top 3 Ways to Prioritize Customer Experience in the Post-Purchase Journey

Let's dive into each of these trends to understand how they’re shaping the future of customer experience.

Female making bead jewelry with tweezers at a desk

Insights to Help Your Business

SMB Shipping Pulse Check Report: How Shipping Experience is Driving CX

Learn how shipping experience is a key component to CX.

Female on her smartphone with shopping bags on her arms

Insights to Help Your Business

Unlock the Secrets of the Upcoming Holiday Shopping Trends

Welcome to The Ultimate 2023 Holiday Shopping Trends Guide!

Semi-truck driving down an empty road surrounded by green land

Insights to Help Your Business

Last Mile Delivery Trends to Get Excited About in 2024

With e-Commerce’s rise in popularity, the last mile has become the most crucial part of the delivery process.

Person in warehouse doing inventory

Insights to Help Your Business

What Are Incoterms and Why Do They Matter in Shipping?

Understanding the meaning of Incoterms and their role in international trade and contracts.

Two packages sitting on a welcome mat in front of a door

Insights to Help Your Business

Protect Shipments from Porch Piracy

Protect against package theft with comprehensive coverage for your business. Learn more on how to build loyalty and trust with your customers.

Male truck driver smiling and looking out the window

Insights to Help Your Business

The Difference Between Shipping Insurance and Carrier Liability

 

Unraveling the secrets of comprehensive coverage and avoiding shipment nightmares.

Female opening a cardboard box from her couch

Insights to Help Your Business

How to Strengthen CX by Empowering Customers with Options

Consumers want to be in the driver seat for their delivery experience. See how the InsureShield® app for Shopify® merchants can support a positive post-purchase experience and give customers more control.

Cargo ship full of shipping containers going through turquoise water

Insights to Help Your Business

Out to Sea

Can your business stay afloat if a container goes overboard?

Two semi trucks driving down the road.

Insights to Help Your Business

2022 Freight Shipping Survey

Learn about the realities associated with shipping freight straight from the people who do it every day.

Woman putting a label on a box in warehouse

Insights to Help Your Business

2022 State of Shipping Study

Prepare for delivery challenges with UPS Capital’s exclusive report.

Male delivering a box with van doors open showing more boxes

Insights to Help Your Business

2022 Last Mile Report

An exclusive look at same-day delivery risks and rewards.

Load More